Pages

Sunday, March 3, 2013

Census

I really think this whole census thing is a lot of bother for nothing. Not as bothersome for us in 2013 as it might have been in the past ...


... but bothersome nonetheless. It seems a very expensive way to collect spurious data. Sneaky smokers aren't going to admit their addiction on their forms, and a lot of people are filling in forms way ahead of census day, both online and off. I thought the whole idea was to get an accurate snapshot of New Zealand on March the 5th. I have not completed my forms yet, because to do so would assume certainty as to my whereabouts on Tuesday evening. Clearly there would have been no point in taking my ticket in last night's Lotto draw if I was assured it would not affect my personal living circumstances by Tuesday (although sadly it did not). And why print all these forms? Why not just give forms to people who are actually going to use them, not to all the online choosers. 

Is this census really going to give us any data that couldn't have been sourced in far easier ways? For well over a hundred years we have been recording every birth and death.


We count everyone who enters or leaves our shores. Surely the government could easily tally all this information and work out very accurately how many people we have, all up. As for the rest of the questions, couldn't a poll of a representative group (say 50,000 to be sure) produce the same results with much less fuss? Businesses and political parties seem happy with much smaller samplings from Colmar-Brunton and the likes.


Still, I suppose it's providing employment to all those enumerators out there - this in itself it going to distort our employment figures marginally and fleetingly - which is why I'm giving mine a little on-going purpose in life by allowing her to return to collect the forms. I guess I'm just a people person!







4 comments:

  1. I've done ours - on-line because we filled out one for each residence. I don't mind this as without census information, government and councils cannot properly predict and provide infrastructure and services. Sure businesses use research methods but a full census is like an adjustment or correction of data.
    On-line is perfect for people who for various reasons cannot guarantee to be at home when the collector calls.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I've done ours too. One wonders what it says about the validity if the dominant male fills in the form for all the residents!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Wrong Second.
    I filled ours out as the dominant female gave me the job to do.

    ReplyDelete